2022-23 NCHA Women's All-Freshman Team
Forward: Bailey Brunnhoelzl, St. Norbert (Palmer, Alaska)
Forward: Tia Lascelle, Adrian (Cornwall, Ontario)
Forward: Makayla Spejcher, Concordia Wisconsin (Green Bay, Wis.)
Defense: Willow Poppleton, Lake Forest (Pickering, Ontario)
Defense: Grace Wittkopf, St. Norbert (Eagle, River, Wis.)
Goalie: Casey Frank, Trine (Cranberry Township, Pa.)

2021-22 NCHA Women's All-Freshman Team
Forward: Peyton Elliott, Aurora (F/Jenison, Mich.)
Forward: Courtnie Hogan, St. Norbert College (F/Hoffman Estates, Ill.)
Forward: Darci Matson, Aurora (F/, Ak.)
Defense: Sophia Chapman, Lake Forest (D/Ann Arbor, Mich.)
Defense: Maddux Federici, St. Norbert (D/Wausau, Wis.)
Defense: Katie Rahilly, Concordia Wisconsin (D/Newberry, Mich.)
Goalie: Ryleigh Furlong, Trine (G/Lakeville, Minn.)
-Additional All-Freshman honoree due to tie in voting

2020-21 NCHA Women's All-Freshman Team
Forward: Allie Bussey, St. Scholastica (Hibbing, Minn.)
Forward: Hannah Cunha, Marian (Havervill, Mass.)
Forward: Callie Wollschlager, Adrian (Bothell, Wash.)
Defense: Lisa LaRoche, St. Scholastica (Minnetonka, Minn.)
Defense: Kathryn Truban, Adrian (Hamilton, N.J.)
Goalie: Tia Glube, Aurora (Oakville, Ontario)
Goalie: Kayla Kolpitcke, Marian (Powell, Wyo.)
-Two goalies due to tie in voting

2019-20 NCHA Women’s All-Freshman Team
Forward: Une Bjelland, Adrian (Stavanger, Norway)
Forward: Lauryn Hull,  St. Scholastica (Kimberly, Wis.)
Forward: Eve Parker, St. Norbert (Verona, Wis.)
Defense: Lauren Arnholt, St. Norbert (Germantown, Wis.)
Defense: Mak Cooke, Aurora (Merritt, British Columbia)
Defense: Karya Dean, Lake Forest (Missoula, Mont.)
Goalie: Annalina Van Hercke, Concordia (Castle Rock, Colo.)
-Additional defense due to tie in voting

2018-19 NCHA Women’s All-Freshman Team
Forward: Theresa DiMaggio, Trine (Shelby Township, Mich.)
Forward: Maddy Millar, Concordia Wisconsin (Anchorage, Alaska)
Forward: Amber Tilander, St. Scholastica (International Falls, Minn.)
Defense: Julia Barrett, Adrian (Wixom, Mich.)
Defense: Olyvia Opsahl, Lake Forest (Duluth, Minn.)
Goalie: Denisa Jandova, Adrian (Vejprnice, Czech Republic)

2017-18 NCHA Women’s All-Freshman Team
Forward: Megan Lyke, Lake Forest (Mounds View, Minn.)
Forward: Nicole McKernan, Aurora (Westminster, Colo.)
Forward: Brooke Schembri, Adrian (Canton, Mich.)
Defense: Rebecca Lilly, Finlandia (Invercargill, New Zealand)
Defense: Jordan Trapp, Lake Forest (Brooklyn Park, Minn.)
Goalie: Kate Turner, Adrian (Houston, Texas)

2016-17 NCHA Women’s All-Freshman Team
Forward: Ally Fox, Marian (Greenville, Wis.)
Forward: Lexi Morgan, Lake Forest (Medina, Ohio)
Forward: Sydney Simone, Lake Forest (Plymouth, Minn.)
Defense: Kelly O’Sullivan, Adrian (Inverness, Ill.)
Defense: Julia Unterseher, Lake Forest (North Oaks, Minn.)
Goalie: Jacque Rogers, Lake Forest (Marysville, Ill.)

2015-16 NCHA Women’s All-Freshman Team
Forward: Amy Budde, Lake Forest College
Forward: Brooke Lupi, Adrian College
Forward: Courtney Wittig, Marian University
Defense: Kennedy Houge, College of St. Scholastica
Defense: Ellie Woodman, Concordia University Wisconsin
Goalie: Christina Pattengale, Concordia University Wisconsin
Goalie: Lindsey Strainis, Marian University
(two goalies due to tie in voting)

2014-15 NCHA Women’s All-Freshman Team
Forward: Reaghan Chadwick, St. Norbert
Forward: Lexi Holman, Concordia Wisconsin
Forward: Abby Sawyer,  St. Scholastica
Defense: Kayla Griffith, Lake Forest
Defense: Tasha Smith, St. Norbert
Goalie: Leigh Grall, St. Norbert

2013-14 NCHA Women's All-Freshman Team
Forward: Kristin Lewicki, Adrian College
Forward: Veronika Metanova, Concordia Wisconsin
Forward: Isabel Waidacher, St. Scholastica
Defense: Megan Crandell, St. Norbert
Defense: Lexie Tzafaroglou, Adrian
Goalie: Lindsey Hartel, St. Scholastica

2012-13 NCHA Women's All-Freshman Team
Forward: Michelle Greeneway, Lake Forest
Forward: Chloe Kinsel, UW-River Falls
Foward: Melissa Paluch, Lake Forest
Defense: Josie Johnson, UW-Stevens Point
Defense: Dani Buehrer, UW-River Falls
Goalie: Megan Leikkari, UW-Superior

2011-12 NCHA Women's All-Freshman Team
Forward: Hannah McGowan, Adrian
Forward: Dani Schlutz, UW-Superior
Forward: Nina Waidacher, St. Scholastica
Defense: Alex Blair, St. Scholastica
Defense: Emily Heckendorf, Concordia Wisconsin
Defense: Courtney Millar, Adrian
Goalie: Jenna Brankin, Lake Forest

2010-11 NCHA Women's All-Freshman Team
Forward: Kait Mason, UW-River Falls
Forward: Lauren Straus, St. Norbert
Forward: Allie Tanzer, UW-Stevens Point
Defense: Emma Agen, St. Norbert
Defense: Sheryl Kaskiw, UW-Superior
Defense: Emily Larson, UW-Eau Claire
Goalie: Emily Michelin, Adrian

2009-10 season and prior coaches didn't vote for All-Freshman Team