| Year | First Team | Second Team | Award | |||
| 2022-23 | Darci Matson, So., F, Aurora | Maya Roy, Jr., D, Adrian | National Player of the Year - Darci Matson | |||
| Sophie, Sr., G, Adrian | Une Bjelland, Sr., D, Adrian | |||||
| Kathryn Truban, Jr., F, Adrian | Jessica VonRuden, Gr., D, Adrian | |||||
| 2021-22 | Chiara Pfosi, Sr, G, Aurora | Darci Matson, Fr, F, Aurora | ||||
| Avan Jaschke, Jr., D, St. Norbert | Kirsten Vandenheuvel, Sr, D, Trine | |||||
| Brandi Wilson, Sr, F, Trine | ||||||
| Olyvia Opsahl, Sr., D, Lake Forest | ||||||
| 2020-21 | No All-Americans due to COVID | |||||
| 2019-20 | Kelly O'Sullivan, Sr, D, Adrian | Denisa Jandova, So, G, Adrian | ||||
| Nicole Guagliardo, Sr., F, Adrian | ||||||
| 2018-19 | Kelly O'Sullivan, JR, Adrian | Lexi Thomeczek, JR, St. Scholastica | ||||
| Rachel Anderson, SO, St. Scholastica | Amy Budde, Sr, Lake Forest | |||||
| 2017-18 | Kelly O'Sullivan, So, D, Adrian | Kate Turner, Fr, G, Adrian | ||||
| Olivia Spellmire, Sr, F, Lake Forest | Kayla Griffith, Sr, D, Lake Forest | |||||
| Kristi Zink, Sr., F, Adrian | ||||||
| 2016-17 | Kelly O'Sullivan, Fr, D, Adrian | Kayla Griffith, Jr, D, Lake Forest | ||||
| Kristin Lewicki, Sr, F, Adrian | Sydney Smith, Sr, D, Adrian | |||||
| Kaylyn Schroka, Sr, F, Adrian | ||||||
| Sarah Shureb, Sr., F, Adrian | ||||||
| 2015-16 | Michelle Greeneway, Sr., F, Lake Forest | Alex Stensland, Sr, D, Lake Forest | National Player of the Year - Michelle Greeneway | |||
| Allie Carter, Sr, G, Lake Forest | Olivia Spellmire, So., F, Lake Forest | |||||
| Kayla Griffith, So, D, Lake Forest | ||||||
| Sydney Smith, Jr, D, Adrian | ||||||
| Kristin Lewicki, Jr, F, Adrian | ||||||
| 2014-15 | Nina Waidacher, Sr, F, St. Scholastica | Jade Walsh, So, G, Adrian | ||||
| Megan Crandell, So, D, St. Norbert | ||||||
| Michelle Greeneway, Jr., F, Lake Forest | ||||||
| 2013-14 | Laurel Hill, Sr., D, St. Norbert | Alex Blair, Jr., D, St. Scholastica | ||||
| Alix Vallee, Sr., D, Adrian | Alex Stensland, So., D, Lake Forest | |||||
| Michelle Greeneway, So., F, Lake Forest | Kelsey Kusch, Jr., F, Adrian | |||||
| Nina Waidacher, Jr., F, St. Scholastica | ||||||
| 2012-13 | Brittany Zeches, Sr, G, Adrian | Alex Blair, So, D, St. Scholastica | ||||
| Amanda Ryder, Sr, D, UW-River Falls | Katie Batters, Jr, F, UW-River Falls | |||||
| Alix Vallee, Jr, D, Adrian | Michelle Greeneway, Fr., F, Lake Forest | |||||
| Kait Mason, Jr, F, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| Nina Waidacher, So, F, St. Scholastica | ||||||
| 2011-12 | Dani Schultz, Fr, F, UW-Superior | Shanley Peters, So, G, UW-Superior | ||||
| Kaiti Graham, Jr, D, UW-Superior | ||||||
| Kelly Salis, Sr, F, Adrian | ||||||
| Katie Batters, So, F, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| Nina Waidacher, Fr., F, St. Scholastica | ||||||
| 2010-11 | Emily Michelin, Fr., G, Adrian | |||||
| Lauren Conrad, Sr., D, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| Kristin Faber, Sr,, F, UW-Eau Claire | ||||||
| Kait Mason, Fr., F, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| 2009-10 | Melissa Kunzelman, Sr., G, UW-Superior | |||||
| Courtney Bean, Sr., D, Lake Forest | ||||||
| Kim Herring, So., F, Lake Forest | ||||||
| 2008-09 | Rachael Graves, Sr., D, UW-Stevens Point | |||||
| Nicole Grossmann, Sr., F, UW-Stevens Point | ||||||
| 2007-08 | Krista Hakala, Jr., D, UW-Superior | |||||
| Gina Baranzelli, Sr., F, UW-Superior | ||||||
| Nicole Grossman, Jr., F, UW-Stevens Point | ||||||
| Jamie Lewandoski, Sr., D, UW-Stevens Point | ||||||
| 2006-07 | Sally Bevis, Sr., G, Lake Forest | |||||
| Amber Lindner, Sr., G, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| Erin Kegley, Sr., F, UW-Superior | ||||||
| 2005-06 | Rikki Nespor, Fr., G, UW-Superior | |||||
| Jenny Wallace, Jr., D, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| Erin Kegley, Jr., F, UW-Superior | ||||||
| 2004-05 | Jenny Wallace, So., D, UW-River Falls | |||||
| Erin Kegley, So., F, UW-Superior | ||||||
| Jackie Schmitt, Sr., F, UW-Stevens Point | ||||||
| 2003-04 | Lindsy Carlson, Sr., D, UW-River Falls | |||||
| Erin Kegley, Fr., F, UW-Superior | ||||||
| 2002-03 | Marlene Yaeger, So., G, UW-River Falls | |||||
| Lindsy Carlson, Jr., D, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| Jackie Schmitt, So., F, UW-Stevens Point | ||||||
| Ali Slinden, Fr., F, UW-River Falls | ||||||
| 2001-02 | Lindsy Carolson, So., D, UW-Superior | |||||
| Ann Ninnemann, Fr., F, UW-Stevens Point | ||||||
| Melanie Salatino, Fr., F, UW-Stevens Point |