Finlandia University - 12
Lukas Alberer, Jr. * ... Robert DeVaun, So. ... CJ Fisher, Jr. ... Travis Hanson, Jr. * ... Joe Junttila, Sr. * ... Kevin Korte, So. ... Matt Lindgren, Jr. * ... Marc Marcotte, So. ... Blake Miller, So. ... Josh Paquette, Jr. * ... Mike Parks, Jr. * ... Ryan Sullivan, So.

Note: Ties Minnesota-Crookston's league standard set in 2003-04 with 12 members

Lawrence University – 10
Ted Greeley , So. ... Jesse Jacobs, So. ... Nick Jennette, So. ... Brian Kennihan, Jr. * ... Aaron LaFave, So. ... Kalle Larsson, Sr. ... Chris Lawson, So. ... Andrew Litchfield, So. ... Austin Montgomery, Jr. ... Josh Peterson, Jr. *

Marian University – 10
Greg Copeland, So. ... Andrew Corvo, So. ... Dave DeSander, Jr. * .... James Goodfellow, So. ... Bill Griffore Jr., So. ... Jason Jadczak, So. ... Kyle Jones, So. ... Josh McAndrew, So. ... Ted Thompson, Jr. ... Jeff Wills, So.

Milwaukee School of Engineering – 8
Nick Bilpush, Sr. * ... Ross Chawansky, Jr. * ... Joe Dovalina, Sr. ... Matt Fastelin, Jr. * ... Josh Rudolph, Sr. # ... Brian Soik, Sr. # ... Jason Woll, So. ... David Yolo, Sr. #

Minnesota-Crookston – 3
Teal Plaine, Jr. # ... Brett Shelanski, Sr. $ ... Ryan Tucker, Jr. *

Northland College – 3
Justin Grant, Sr. * ... Jim Junker, Sr. # ... Steve O’Hern, Sr. *

Note: * = Two-Time All-Academic member
# = Three-time All-Academic member
$ = Four-time All-Academic member