2021-22 All-Americans
First Team
Cameron Gray, Sr., G, Adrian
Matt Eller, Sr., D, Adrian
Brayden Sampson, Sr., D, Aurora
Peter Bates, Sr., F, St. Norbert
Alessio Luchiani, Jr., F, Adrian
Second Team
Peyton Frantti, Sr., St. Norbert
Sam Ruffin, Sr., Adrian
2020-21 All-Americans
2019-20 All-Americans
First Team
Joey Colatarci, SR, D, Adrian
Dino Balsamo, SR, F, Adrian
Peter Bates, JR, F, St. Norbert
Second Team
Josh Boyko, JR, G, Aurora
Mark DerManulian, JR, D, Lake Forest
2018-19 All-Americans
First Team
Luke Davison, SO, St. Norbert
Cory Dunn, SR, Adrian
Riley Christensen, SR, St. Norbert
Second Team
Hunter Vorva, JR, Marian
Braden Hellems, SR, Adrian
Roman Uchyn, SR, St. Norbert
2017-18 All-Americans
First Team
T. J. Black, Jr, G, St. Norbert
Sean Campbell, Sr, D, St. Norbert
Cory Dunn, Jr, D, Adrian
Tanner Froese, Sr, F, St. Norbert
Mathew Thompson, Sr, F, Adrian
Second Team
Braydon Barker, Fr, D, Concordia Wisconsin
Lane King, Sr, F, Lawrence
Taylor McCloy, Sr, F, Adrian
Hunter Stewart, Sr, F, Marian
2016-17 All-Americans
First Team
T.J. Black, So, G, St. Norbert
Cory Dunn, So, D, Adrian
Jack Lewis, Sr, F, Lake Forest
Second Team
Sean Campbell, Jr, D, St. Norbert
Gianni Mangone, Jr, D, Marian
Trevor Boyd, So, F, Adrian
2015-16 All-Americans
First Team
Chris Leone, Sr, D, Adrian
Erik Cooper, Sr, F, St. Norbert
Second Team
Cory Dunn, FY, D, Adrian
Blake Thompson, Jr, D, St. Norbert
Dylan Nowakowski, Sr, F, St. Scholastica
2014-15 All-Americans
First Team
Leo Podolsky, Jr, G, Lake Forest
Marian Fiala, Sr, D, St. Norbert
Kyle Brothers, Fr, F, Adrian
Josh Ranalli, Sr, F, Adrian
Second Team
Ryan Gieseler, Sr, D, Adrian
Michael Hill, Jr, F, St. Norbert
2013-14 All-Americans
First Team
David Jacobson, Jr, G, St. Norbert
Joe Perry, Sr, D, St. Norbert
Second Team
Marian Fiala, Jr, D, St. Norbert
Mason Baptista, Jr, F, St. Norbert
Duston Hebebrand, Jr, F, Adrian
2012-13 All-Americans
Zach Graham, Sr, F, Adrian
Shaquille Merasty, Fr, F, Adrian
2011-12 All-Americans
Conor Toomey, Sr, G, MSOE
Christ Stansik, Sr, D, Adrian
Zach Graham, Jr, F, Adrian
Jordan Keizer, Jr, F, MSOE
2010-11 All-Americans
First Team
Shawn Skelly, Sr, F, Adrian
Second Team
Dakota Dubetz, Marian
Connor Toomey, MSOE
2009-10 All-Americans
Second Team
Mike Dahlinger, Adrian
Chris Stansik, Adrian
2008-09 All-Americans
Second Team
Adram Krug, Sr, Adrian
2007-08 All-Americans
Second Team
Adam Krug, Jr, Adrian
2006-07 All-Americans
Second Team
Brian Soik, Sr, F, MSOE
No All-Americans from 1998-99 to 2005-06.